INSIGHTS

Debt consolidation loan pros and cons: a balanced guide

The benefits, the risks, and how to tell if it fits you

A debt consolidation loan replaces several debts with one loan, one rate and one repayment. The main benefits are simpler repayments and often lower interest. The main risks are a higher total cost over a longer term and running the cleared debts back up.

Key takeaways

  • Consolidation works best when the new loan's rate is lower than the average rate on your current debts.
  • Lower weekly repayments do not always mean a cheaper loan. Check the total cost, not just the repayment.
  • Lenders look at your whole credit profile, not only your credit score.
  • The loan only helps if you stop adding new debt to the cards and accounts you pay off.

Can I consolidate my debts into one loan?

Yes, in most cases you can consolidate your debts into one loan. A lender pays out your existing balances, such as credit cards, store cards, buy now pay later accounts and personal loans. You then repay the lender through one fixed repayment schedule.

Whether you qualify depends on your income, your current debt levels and your recent repayment history. Under New Zealand's Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA), lenders must check that the new loan is affordable for you before they approve it.

Advantages of a debt consolidation loan

One repayment and one due date

Juggling four or five due dates is how payments get missed. One repayment on a set day is easier to budget for and easier to automate.

A lower rate on high-interest debt

Credit cards and store cards often carry high rates. If the consolidation loan's rate is lower, more of each repayment goes to the balance and less goes to interest.

A fixed end date

A credit card has no finish line. A consolidation loan with a fixed rate and a fixed term tells you exactly when you will be debt-free, provided you keep up the repayments.

Less stress and more breathing room

Fewer bills and a lower repayment can ease the week-to-week pressure. Nomu Finance customers have told us that consolidating helped them get lower repayments and some extra breathing room.

A chance to rebuild your credit record

Paying off revolving balances and then making on-time repayments builds a positive record. Research from TransUnion found that borrowers who used personal loans to consolidate reduced their credit card balances by 57% on average.

Disadvantages of a debt consolidation loan

A longer term can cost more overall

Stretching debt over more years lowers the repayment but raises the total interest. Here is an illustrative example, with fees ignored. A $12,000 loan at 15% p.a. costs about $416 a month over three years, with roughly $3,000 in interest. Over five years, the repayment drops to about $285 a month, but the interest rises to roughly $5,100.

The new loan is not always cheaper

Establishment fees and the rate you are offered decide whether consolidation saves money. If your offered rate is close to what you already pay, the saving is small or nil.

Qualifying is not guaranteed

Recent defaults, arrears, lots of credit enquiries or tight affordability can lead to a decline or a higher rate. Each lender sets its own criteria.

The cleared cards can fill up again

This is the biggest risk. If you keep the paid-off cards open and use them, you end up with the new loan plus fresh card debt. Close the accounts or lower the limits once they are cleared.

Pros and cons at a glance

FactorProCon
RepaymentsOne fixed amount on one dateA lower amount over a longer term can cost more in total
InterestA lower rate on high-interest balancesFees and the offered rate can cancel out the saving
TimelineA clear finish dateYou may be in debt for longer
Credit recordOn-time repayments build a positive historyA new application adds a credit enquiry
BehaviourFewer accounts to manageCleared cards can be run up again

When debt consolidation makes sense

Consolidation is usually a good fit when most of these apply to you:

  • Most of your debt sits on high-interest cards, store cards or short-term loans.
  • You are paying several creditors and finding the due dates hard to manage.
  • Your income is stable enough to cover the new repayment with room to spare.
  • You are ready to stop using the accounts you pay off.

Consolidation is a weaker fit if your debts are already on low rates, if you are close to paying them off, or if your income does not cover your basic costs. In that last case, a new loan will not fix the underlying shortfall.

Alternatives to a consolidation loan

New Zealand's Sorted money guidance and free financial mentors raise the same point. Consolidation is one tool among several, and the right choice depends on the size of your debt and your income.

Balance transfer credit card

A balance transfer moves card debt to a new card with a low introductory rate. It suits smaller balances you can clear before the introductory period ends. After that, the rate usually reverts to a standard card rate.

Budgeting help and repayment arrangements

Free financial mentors, which you can reach through MoneyTalks, can help you build a budget and talk to your creditors about hardship arrangements. No new loan is involved.

Formal insolvency options

A Debt Repayment Order, a No Asset Procedure or bankruptcy are last-resort options for debt you cannot realistically repay. They carry serious, long-lasting effects on your credit, so get independent advice first.

Your decision checklist

  1. List every debt with its balance, rate and minimum repayment.
  2. Work out the total you would pay if you keep your current debts.
  3. Compare that with the total cost of the consolidation loan, including fees.
  4. Choose the shortest term with a repayment you can comfortably afford.
  5. Decide now which cards you will close or reduce once they are paid off.
  6. Check your credit file for errors before you apply.

How Nomu Finance approaches debt consolidation

Debt consolidation is one of the core lending purposes Nomu Finance covers. We assess every application individually. We do not set a minimum credit score. Instead, we look at your overall credit profile, including:

  • the nature, value and age of any defaults or arrears
  • your recent repayment conduct and current debt levels
  • credit enquiry activity
  • affordability, income and employment stability
  • any security you can offer

Lenders on our panel offer fixed rates for debt consolidation loans of up to 29.95% p.a. An applicant with a low score may still be eligible with some lenders, while someone with a higher score may not qualify because of other parts of their profile. Eligibility is always subject to each lender's requirements. Turnaround times depend on how complete your application is and whether we need more information.

The online application takes about five minutes. Start your application to see whether a consolidation loan fits your situation.

Ready to get started?

Find out what you could borrow in minutes.

Related guides

No items found.

The information in this article is general in nature and is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial advice and should not be relied on as a substitute for personalised advice tailored to your individual circumstances.

Third-party information, rates, fees, and product details referenced in this article were current at the time of writing and are subject to change. Always confirm current details directly with the relevant company before making any decision.

Any examples, figures, or scenarios in this article are illustrative only and do not represent a credit offer or guarantee of approval. Lending criteria apply.

Nomu Finance Limited (FSP1011169) holds a Class 1 Financial Advice Provider (FAP) licence issued by the Financial Markets Authority. Personalised financial advice is only provided following a full assessment of your individual needs and circumstances by a Nomu Finance adviser.

If you are considering taking out a loan or making any financial decision, we encourage you to speak with an independent licensed financial adviser or get in touch with one of the team at Nomu, to get advice tailored to your circumstances.